by Kelly Cooper
Lawyers that regularly litigate in the probate world always have an improbable story to tell. Here is one of those stories that ended up in front of the North Dakota Supreme Court last year:
A couple, Lee and Robyn, were engaged and planned to be married on July 18, 2009. On June 26, 2009, Lee and Robyn signed a prenuptial agreement that required Lee to make gifts to Robyn and her daughter upon his death.
Also on June 26, 2009, Lee executed a Will that contained the provisions to comply with the requirements of the prenuptial agreement. The Will gave property to Robyn, describing her as “my wife, Robyn.” The Will also stated, “My spouse’s name is Robyn Risovi and all references in this Will to “my spouse” are to her only.” However, a footnote followed stating, “This Will has been prepared in anticipation of the upcoming marriage of …Lee Paulson and Robyn Risovi set for July 18, 2009.”
Lee died on July 15, 2009 – three days before the wedding.
Before you read any further, answer this question: should Robyn receive the gifts under the Will even though she was not yet Lee’s wife?